RE: I know..... -
10-29-2002, 02:34 PM
Rabell, wacha kucomplain...you started it remember? Are you using a TI ama gani hiyo unatumia.
BigG....dude where the heck have you been hibernating? Dang....thanks for resureccting though..with memory intact too Im still very much around!
Shida: ayaaye..now look what we end up with!
"if you and I know the truth then it must be the truth?"
There goes the major confusion, the A=B AND A not equal B stuff..all at the same time.
If you model the probability universe for truth..how do you incorporate falsehood? Do you include it as part of truth?
MODEL 1: UNIVERSE = KNOWLEDGE = P(1)
In this Universe you can dichotomize the subsets into two main ones, one half being the truth and the other half being falsehood right? Then the existense of Rabell's knowledge in this universe would be partly in the truth and partly in the falsehood sections.
P(truth) + P(falsehood) = P(knowledge) =1
P(Rabells knowledge) = P(K(truth))+P(L(falsehood)
where K and L denote fractions of truth and knowledge that Rabell has
For Rabell to know that we/Juma does not know, it implies that the sphere of Juma's knowledge is all contained within the existense of Rabell's knowledge right?
P(jumas knowledge) = P(M(rabell's knowledge))
on condition that K = 0
But as per the solution we have obtained
P (A.B) = 1
P(whole truth) = P(Juma's knowledge) + P (Rabell's knowledge)
but since Juma's knowlege is contained within Rabell's knowlege it reduces to
P(whole truth) = P (Rabell's knowledge)
In essence Rabell is claiming to know the whole truth? Rabell dont you think that is pushing it a little bit?
So in essense Rabell knows EVERYTHING juma knows and it is only this information that will enable him to determine that Juma does not know the truth or so to speak?
Juma's existense in the knowledge world thus is engulfed by Rabell's knowledge (which could imply that Juma is retarded or dumb LOL) which in this case Rabell also knows both the truth and the falsehood.
Now that is the thing that makes it a dilemna how can Rabell claim to know everything that Juma knows?
Rabell can you answer that question...
and Shida can you model those into equations hehehehe (dude...its called practising yawa).
Lily dear...your input is very much valued. Come back here.
|