[Coach]

satjas,
>>The verse you just quoted is not dealing with
>>apostasy but with a certain war. Read the verse again,
>>sloooooowly
>
>you know what Coach, it doesn't blooming matter whether it
>regards apostasy or not ..its ABOUT THE FACT THAT YOUR ALLAH
>HAS MADE IT CLEAR THAT HE KILLS!!!
>ok, wasn't shouting, only emphasizing a similar point as to
>when you say " can the koooran be any clearer than that"?????

God gives life and God takes life, didn't you know that? When the cells in your body degenerate, your spirit is no longer able to stay in its vessel and it eventually leaves and goes back to God. When someone is killed in a car-crash and the body cannot sustain the spirit, it also leaves this earthly life to be reunited with God. So God does kill and God does give life, earthly life that is!


>dude, forget about apostasy, your fellow brethren were ready
>to murder (kill) simply for some silly cartoons...check out
>the news, some guys have been arrested for soliciting
>murder......can it be more clearer than that????


Alas, I thought you were adressing the issue at hand and not fishing out for another argument. You should have informed me since your response seemed so incoherent with my question.

You are consistently illogical for someone who is constantly trying to appeal to people's logic! If parents raise their children well and teach them right from wrong, and then some of these children choose to go against the teachings of their parents, do you still blame the parents?

Cartoon issue again? Didn't you see the verse...

"Whoever kills a person without his being guilty of murder or of creating unrest in the land, is as though he kills the whole of mankind." (Al-Ma’idah, 5: 32)

Do you believe their actions are legitimised by Islam? Please show me where it says kill whomsoever annoys or offends your Prophet. The Prophet went through a lot of humiliation in the hands of polytheists, but he was nothing but kind to them. He was spat at, pelted with stones, thorns put on his path as he went for the dawn prayers, threatenned, mocked etc.


You are being illogical in constantly blaming Islam for the actions of Muslims. Your problem is with Islam and you therefore use the actions of all the extremists as arsenal to support your arguments.